We Know The Traitors

Rob’s Reactions to The Traitors Episode 9

Welcome to RHAP's coverage of ALL the Traitors iterations from around the world, including New Zealand, Australia, and Canada. The Traitors US is a high-stakes reality competition set in a secluded castle, where contestants must work together to complete challenges and earn a prize pot—while rooting out the secret traitors hidden among them.

Today, Rob Cesternino and Pooya break down the twists, strategies, and shifting alliances among the remaining castle players. As friendships are exposed and traitors quietly maneuver, Rob and Pooya revisit pivotal voting blocks, surprise shortlist decisions, and clever gameplay, offering keen analysis on the evolving landscape of this reality competition.

The podcast explores the multifaceted vote that sends Stephen Colletti home, featuring a unique 5-2-2 split and sharp insight into how pairs like Tara and Johnny, and Mark and Kristen, drive the action. Rob and Pooya unpack the mission’s meta-strategy where traitors cleverly channel suspicion, only for the faithful to stumble, sparking confusion and intrigue. The episode also looks at the fresh challenge of the death shortlist, and how self-preservation changes voting behavior, especially for those marked for elimination.

Listeners are treated to candid takes on the growing dynamics, including the faithful’s infighting, Kristen’s direct confrontation with Eric, and Eric’s rookie struggles as a newly recruited traitor. The looming presence of Rob Rausch—a master of subtle manipulation—and the comedic contrast with Eric’s anxious gameplay spark fun debate. The hosts examine murder tactics after the roundtable, shifting suspicions, and what the faithful need to do to mount a comeback.

Key points discussed:


The strategic vote split and why certain pairs target differing suspects


How traitors hide in plain sight and influence the roundtable


The group’s approach to the murder shortlist and its impact on vote strategy


Kristen’s kitchen confrontation with Eric and its potential fallout


Rob Rausch’s tactical use of alliances, crediting others for his choices

Can Tara and Johnny’s newfound friendship help them survive, or will the traitors keep dictating the flow until the finale? Unravel the chess moves, personality clashes, and bold calls as the endgame approaches.

Chapters:00:00 Intros06:00 Hand-Wringing Over Episode Stakes12:00 Johnny and Tara Targeted18:00 Traitors Master Vote Manipulation24:00 Mission Strategy Breaks the Game30:00 Faithfuls Create Chaotic Aftermath36:00 Shortlist Alters Survival Strategy42:00 Kristen Confronts Eric Directly48:00 Eric Flounders as New Traitor54:00 Tara and Johnny’s Alliance Unfolds01:00:00 Gamers Reshape Traitors Gameplay01:06:00 Faithful Win Conditions Speculated01:12:00 Stephen’s Banished: "You Blew It"

Never miss all our Traitors US recaps plus recaps from other versions around the world!LISTEN: Subscribe to The Traitors Around the World podcast feedWATCH:  Subscribe to the podcast on YouTubeSUPPORT:  Become a RHAP Patron for bonus content, access to Facebook and Discord groups plus more great perks!

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Traitors US S4 Week 6 Exit Interview w/ Banished Player

Welcome to RHAP's coverage of ALL the Traitors iterations from around the world, including New Zealand, Australia, and Canada. The Traitors US is a high-stakes reality competition set in a secluded castle, where contestants must work together to complete challenges and earn a prize pot—while rooting out the secret traitors hidden among them.

The We Know Traitors podcast welcomes Stephen Colletti, fresh from his recent banishment on The Traitors. Host Pooya sits down with Stephen to dig into the pivotal moments that led to his exit from the castle—including game twists, shifting alliances, and a few frustrating misunderstandings. Stephen sheds light on how one banquet, a roast mix-up, and some questionable gut instincts among the players turned his game upside down.

Stephen breaks down how the infamous tarot card incident becomes his undoing and reflects on missed clues left by Candiace and the tangled alliances with Johnny and Tara. The conversation dives into Stephen’s perspective on Natalie’s influence, unpacking how suspicion shifts and why clear explanations sometimes fall on deaf ears in a high-pressure game. Stephen also opens up about his relationships with allies like Mark and Kristen, the reality of navigating trust and strategy, and how entering the house with and without pre-existing bonds changes everything.


Stephen reveals frustration over being accused due to misunderstandings around the roast and the tarot cards


Analysis of Candiace’s strategic vote and how Stephen and Johnny fail to connect the breadcrumbs


Insights into Natalie’s gut-driven play and how it drives suspicion despite weak evidence


Discussion of alliance dynamics, especially between Johnny and Tara, and how trust shapes gameplay decisions


Reflections on the emotional aftermath of reality TV, Stephen’s lessons from Laguna Beach, and his openness to taking on the Traitor role in the future

Did Natalie’s hunch really seal Stephen’s fate, or were there bigger game forces at work in the castle? Explore how shifting alliances and gut instincts can flip the game, and decide for yourself if Stephen’s strategies gave him the best shot.

Chapters:00:00 Intros01:00 The Roast, Tarot, and Downfall02:36 Missed Alliances and Critical Breadcrumbs03:30 Assigning Blame for Banishment05:01 Trust and Bonds Tested06:27 Reality TV Experience Reflected08:35 Would Stephen Choose Traitor Now?09:45 Shifting Alliances and Farewell

Never miss all our Traitors US recaps plus recaps from other versions around the world!LISTEN: Subscribe to The Traitors Around the World podcast feedWATCH:  Subscribe to the podcast on YouTubeSUPPORT:  Become a RHAP Patron for bonus content, access to Facebook and Discord groups plus more great perks!

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Traitors S4 Ep 9 Recap w/ Sandra Diaz Twine

Welcome to RHAP's coverage of ALL the Traitors iterations from around the world, including New Zealand, Australia, and Canada. The Traitors US is a high-stakes reality competition set in a secluded castle, where contestants must work together to complete challenges and earn a prize pot—while rooting out the secret traitors hidden among them.

Today, Pooya and special guest, Sandra Diaz Twine, discuss The Traitors US S4 Episode 9.

With Rob at the Traitors Reunion, Pooya recaps The Traitors Season 4, Episode 9 alongside special guest Sandra Diaz-Twine. Together, they break down a deceptively dense episode that reshapes the endgame, beginning with Eric’s decision to accept the traitor ultimatum and officially join Rob in the turret

The discussion focuses on Eric’s adjustment to life as a traitor, including his increased nervousness, shifting behavior, and how those changes begin to draw suspicion from Kristen. Sandra and Pooya debate whether Eric’s visible discomfort could become a liability, or if Rob’s protection and social dominance will be enough to keep him insulated.

They analyze Dorinda’s murder and why her removal made strategic sense, particularly given her connections and lack of heat. The pair also breaks down the music box challenge, explaining why the traitors deliberately fed the faithful misleading information and why they avoided being placed on the final shortlist.

At the round table, attention turns to Johnny and Stephen, with Pooya and Sandra dissecting how circumstantial evidence, such as past advocacy from Candace and Lisa, continues to follow them despite both being faithful. They also discuss Natalie being labeled the most manipulative player, her visible frustration, and how that perception may put her in danger.

The episode closes with a forward-looking assessment of the remaining murder options, weighing Natalie versus Kristen, and why Rob’s position appears nearly untouchable regardless of the outcome. With only two episodes left, Pooya and Sandra frame Episode 9 as a critical setup chapter that solidifies Rob’s control while narrowing the faithful’s already-limited paths to victory.

LISTEN: Subscribe to The Traitors Around the World podcast feedWATCH:  Subscribe to the podcast on YouTubeSUPPORT:  Become a RHAP Patron for bonus content, access to Facebook and Discord groups plus more great perks!

Never miss all our Traitors US recaps plus recaps from other versions around the world!
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Rachel Reilly Talks The Traitors S4 Ep 8

Welcome to RHAP's coverage of ALL the Traitors iterations from around the world, including New Zealand, Australia, and Canada. The Traitors US is a high-stakes reality competition set in a secluded castle, where contestants must work together to complete challenges and earn a prize pot—while rooting out the secret traitors hidden among them.

Rob Cesternino and Pooya welcome special guest Rachel Reilly to the Feedback Show. With two traitors gone for a second consecutive week, the trio breaks down shifting alliances, messy gameplay, and how reality TV relationships reshape the competition. Rachel brings her signature insight from both The Traitors and Big Brother, questioning decisions and celebrating the show’s evolving style.

Conversations center on the standout influence of wardrobe, with Rachel and Rob reflecting on how U.S. contestants bring fashion to the forefront, unlike their international counterparts. Attention shifts to this season’s strategy: the impact of getting out the “gamers” early, the intense focus on Rob Rausch’s rise as an unexpected traitor, and how his social game keeps the faithfuls on his side. The dynamic between the Housewives—especially their reluctance (or not) to vote each other out—gets a closer look, as Rachel ponders whether this forms a lasting in-game alliance or just fuels more drama.

Rachel, Rob, and Pooya dissect the traitor-on-traitor clash between Rob and Candiace, the faith placed in Rob by the other contestants, and the tough choices facing new recruit Eric in the turret. The group also shares casting advice, predictions for the season finale, and behind-the-scenes tales from breakfast drama to the chat BCC group’s wild moments.

Traitor-versus-traitor moves outside the turret—how open conflict shapes suspicion

The evolving role of “gamers” versus celebs and the fallout of gamer-heavy early boots

Housewives alliance: myth or reality? When loyal friendships blur strategic lines

Casting advice for civilian hopefuls—why being a sleuth matters more than mission performance

Predictions for endgame: Will Rob cruise to a solo win, or will someone finally catch on to his moves?

With fashion statements, new alliances, and questions of loyalty at play, The Traitors Season 4 sets up a tense endgame. Who will spot the clues, and how will friendships and strategy collide as the roundtable heats up?

Chapters:00:00 The Traitors Wardrobe Revolution06:04 Traitor-on-Traitor Showdown Unfolds10:32 Housewife Alliances Face Scrutiny13:32 Gamer Numbers Strategically Dwindle16:47 Faithfuls Losing Strategic Voice21:12 Johnny Targeted, Alliance Falters24:19 Shields Change Faithful Dynamics28:49 All-Stars and International Crossover32:02 Casting Advice for Civilian Applicants34:57 Best Big Brother Traitor Candidates36:55 Eric Faces Trader Dilemma40:06 Traitor Murder Dilemma Deepens42:08 Salmon Breakfast Sparks Rivalries42:54 Rob’s Solo Traitor Endgame Prediction

Never miss all our Traitors US recaps plus recaps from other versions around the world!LISTEN: Subscribe to The Traitors Around the World podcast feedWATCH:  Subscribe to the podcast on YouTubeSUPPORT:  Become a RHAP Patron for bonus content, access to Facebook and Discord groups plus more great perks!

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Traitors US S4 Week 5 Interview w/ Banished Player

Welcome to RHAP's coverage of ALL the Traitors iterations from around the world, including New Zealand, Australia, and Canada. The Traitors US is a high-stakes reality competition set in a secluded castle, where contestants must work together to complete challenges and earn a prize pot—while rooting out the secret traitors hidden among them.

Rob Cesternino and Pooya sit down with Candiace Dillard Bassett for an exit interview following her dramatic departure from The Traitors. The conversation explores how suspicion, betrayal, and missed opportunities shaped Candiace’s game, offering a closer look at the alliances and undercurrents inside the castle. Listeners get a firsthand account of what it was like to navigate shifting loyalties, cunning traitors, and the unique pressure of the marble room.

Candiace reflects on her efforts to steer attention toward Rob R., sharing her frustration when both the players and viewers overlooked her warnings. She discusses what went down in the turret—including the moment Rob let her choose who to eliminate—and reveals her biggest gameplay regret about not recruiting Kristen. The trio also revisit the tense confrontation in the library, where Candiace famously called out Rob for setting her up. The episode rounds out with talk of the growing suspicions among the faithfuls, Candiace’s thoughts on the dagger ceremony’s non-verbal cues, and a peek at her music career’s latest chapter.

Dive into:

-Candiace’s attempts to cast suspicion on Rob R. and the faithfuls’ refusal to consider her claims

-Rob’s peace offering in the turret and how it signaled potential betrayal in the Traitors’ ranks

-The pivotal library confrontation where Candiace confronted Rob and named him a snake

-Missed opportunities to recruit Kristen and how that might have changed the game’s trajectory

-Non-verbal signals at the dagger ceremony and questions Candiace plans to raise at the reunion

Do Candiace’s suspicions hold up, and will the reunion bring clarity to Rob and Colton’s alliance? Tune in for an unfiltered look into the mind games and strategies fueling The Traitors.

Chapters:00:00 Conga Line and Castle Memories01:36 Frustration Targeting Rob R.02:38 Rob's Red Flag Peace Offering03:32 Regrets Over Not Recruiting04:22 Suspicions About Rob's Signals06:04 Confrontation: "You Set Me Up"08:40 New Single and Future Plans

Never miss all our Traitors US recaps plus recaps from other versions around the world!LISTEN: Subscribe to The Traitors Around the World podcast feedWATCH:  Subscribe to the podcast on YouTubeSUPPORT:  Become a RHAP Patron for bonus content, access to Facebook and Discord groups plus more great perks!

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices