I Know What You Watched in the 90s (and early 2000s)

Happy December! Our episode on 2003s “Elf” may be one of the most wholesome ones we’ve ever done, and I don’t know what it says about our brand that it’s also one our shortest. We hope listening to the three of us agree on what we like about a movie is a peaceful way to end the year, but if not I’m sure we’ll have plenty to disagree on in 2026. Happy Holidays!

It's two IKWYWIT90S firsts - a BRAND-NEW special guest AND our first/(maybe last?) DCOM (Disney Channel Original Movie)! It may also be one of the episodes in which we most equally discuss the good (Grandma's bag, Sophie, the concept of Halloweentown); the bad (the execution of Halloweentown, Marnie and Dylan's teenage-ness); and the ugly (apparently "handsome" Luke). This one's unapologetically for all of our 1998 mortal-kids-wishing-they-were-witches!

Some lessons from our episode about 2002s "The Ring": - Bryant doesn't like scary movies. - You can't convince us that Aidan wasn't haunted, and potentially a butler. - Today's PG-13 movies are not trying hard enough to be as good as "The Ring." - Saying "that's what makes it scary" is a good way to justify not understanding why something is happening. - This is a good scary movie... and Bryant doesn't like scary movies.

It might be a good thing that Jason didn't join the conversation about 1995s "Mighty Morphin Power Rangers" because we're not sure how well he would have handled listening to the rest of us gush about this cool movie with its cool soundtrack and cool skydiving moves and COOL NINJA RANGERS. Even if you don't agree, hopefully you'll still support our petition for a prequel about Zordon, Ivan Ooze, and Dulcea's history.

We would all pay good money to know the when and how it was decided we would watch 1991s "Cool as Ice," but also we're not mad at it 😂 We ARE full of questions such as, what amount of time does this movie span? Is it or is it not supposed to be Vanilla Ice? What's up with tomorrow?