Woke “scholars” say childhood sexual innocence is a “colonial fiction” that must be dismantled
This week’s episode of Citation Needed is available exclusively for our paying supporters. Every other episode of the show is free, so you can always try those first and see if you enjoy what we do—but if you want access to every episode (double the content), you’ll need to become a supporter. Your subscription helps us keep exposing the wildest corners of academia and ensures we can keep producing independent, unfiltered commentary.In this episode, Colin breaks down one of the most disturbing academic papers we’ve ever covered—a peer-reviewed article that doesn’t just question the idea of childhood sexual innocence, but calls for it to be dismantled entirely. The authors argue that society should stop viewing children as needing protection from sexuality, claiming that “childhood pleasure is indispensable” to building a “just sexual future.” They describe “pre-adolescent children’s erotic capacities” as being “pathologized” and call innocence itself a “colonial fiction” that must be “challenged, reinvented, and reinterpreted.” They even go so far as to propose integrating “erotics” into sex education and reframing children as “pleasurable beings.” It’s not hyperbole — this is real scholarship published by the American Sociological Association, and it’s laying the intellectual groundwork for policies that dismantle important safeguards for children against sexual predators.Then, in a rapid-fire lightning round, Colin highlights two more jaw-dropping examples of academia at its worst: a paper claiming that scientists conducting field research abroad are oppressive colonizers and a doctoral dissertation based on communing with “spirit guides,” rabbits, and ancestral archetypes as “data.” But it’s not all bad. Colin wraps up with an example of science done right: a rigorous critique of “transgender brain” research that debunks myths and shows how evidence-based methods should actually look. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.citationneededpodcast.com
--------
29:21
--------
29:21
What ’puppygirls‘ know (and we wish we didn’t), with Eva Kurilova
This week’s episode is free, but remember—we paywall every other episode. That means next week’s is for supporters only. If you want access to double the content and don’t want to miss out, become a paying subscriber. Your support helps us keep exposing the most unhinged corners of academia.This week, Colin is joined by Canadian writer Eva Kurilova to tackle one of the strangest academic papers we’ve ever read: “What Puppygirls Know? The (in)Human Pedagogy of a Trans Feminine Style,” published in the journal Australian Feminist Studies by Taylor & Francis.Yes, you read that right—puppygirls. As in, trans lesbians (i.e., straight men) who identify as puppies. The paper earnestly explores this “erotic style” as a legitimate transgender identity and even suggests that defining transness with humans as the point of reference is “ciscentric.” We go through the author’s immersion in “puppygirl culture,” their claims about consent and dehumanization, and wonder how in the world this paper got published as serious peer-reviewed scholarship.Along the way, we’ll ask whether this is just fetish blogging dressed up as scholarship, laugh at some of the paper’s more absurd passages (complete with ridiculous figures), and reflect on how far gender studies has strayed from reality.Collar up, grab some treats, and watch one of the most awkward and disturbing episodes we’ve aired. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.citationneededpodcast.com
--------
39:46
--------
39:46
Decolonizing and indigenizing nursing with Amy Hamm
This week’s episode of Citation Needed is for supporters only—but don’t worry, next week’s will be free. We alternate between free and paywalled episodes every week, so if you want a taste of what you’re missing, be sure to tune in next week or check out our previous free episodes. And if you enjoy this show, please consider becoming a supporter—it help… This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.citationneededpodcast.com
--------
55:13
--------
55:13
A new paper by a ‘nonspeaking cyborg kraken’ says society is oppressive because most people speak and hear
This week’s episode of Citation Needed is free to everyone! Every other episode is for supporters only, so if you enjoy this one and want to tune in next week, be sure to subscribe. Your support helps us keep producing the show and exposing the ideological rot in academia.In our first segment, we dig into a brand-new paper on “ableism” by activist Alice Wong. Instead of research, the journal published what amounts to a personal diary entry—laced with profanity—arguing that society is oppressive because most people communicate through speaking and hearing. The author describes herself as a “nonspeaking cyborg kraken” and insists that the “medical industrial complex” is an act of violence against her. We break it down and show how this kind of ideology turns lived experience into scholarship while demanding the impossible: that the basic norms of society be completely reoriented around fringe outliers.Then, in our second segment, we try something new: a lightning round of ridiculous abstracts published just in the last two weeks as theses or peer-reviewed papers. We can’t devote an entire episode to every one of them, but this rapid-fire tour shows just how common this unserious, ideological work has become in academia. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.citationneededpodcast.com
--------
34:28
--------
34:28
‘Queer’ researcher says keeping records of child abuse is ‘settler-colonial violence’
This episode is supporters only. We paywall every other episode, which means next week’s episode is free—a perfect way to sample the show and decide if you want to subscribe to receive double the content. Your support helps us keep producing this content.For our first segment, we cover the latest Gordon Guyatt scandal. The “father of evidence-based medicine” tries to paint the Society for Evidence-Based Gender Medicine (SEGM) as biased while admitting, in a new interview with Jesse Singal, that social pressure and PR optics drove him to distance himself from the one group doing rigorous systematic reviews—and even to push ideological language into those reviews. We unpack the contradictions, the pressure campaign, and what this means for science when politics comes first.Plus, in our second segment, we examine a Master’s thesis out of UBC arguing Canada’s child welfare system should stop keeping records of child abuse because documentation disproportionately leads to Indigenous children entering foster care. We analyze the thesis and explain why abolishing records would erase accountability, hide patterns of harm, and put vulnerable kids—especially those facing neglect, violence, and disability—in harm’s way. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.citationneededpodcast.com
New Zealand