2180 episodes
Barry Soper: Newstalk ZB's Senior Political Correspondent on the role of political editors, their importance
19/11/2026 | 5 mins.A long time political editor and correspondent is reiterating the importance of an organisation having a dedicated political editor.
TVNZ has proposed a restructure, which includes scrapping the role and folding its press gallery reporters into a more general reporting structure.
But Barry Soper says the political editors are an important point of contact within a particular organisation, for senior politicians.
He told Kerre Woodham political editors tend to spend the most amount of time with politicians and the Prime Minister, which means they become a first port of call and a touchstone.
Soper says reporters can be this, but not to the same extent.
LISTEN ABOVE
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.- Linda Clark, one of TVNZ's former political editors, now barrister, has written in the Spinoff of the desperate need for media organisations to retain their political editors. TVNZ has proposed a restructure of its news and current affairs operation that includes disestablishing the political editor role and folding parliamentary press gallery reporters into a more general reporting structure. We here at Newstalk ZB don't have a political editor at the moment, we've been trying to fill the role. In the absence of one though, we can call upon the services of Barry Soper, who has years of institutional, invaluable knowledge.
Linda says the political editor's job is in part to understand how issues, people, and Parliament are connected, because consumers of news want help to know what is important and what is worth their time. Do you, you consumers of news, do you? Do you want somebody there to sift through what's important, what is not? She says you can sort the difference, if you have a good political editor, between news and spin. You can't do that without the experience of gallery reporting, she writes, and covering many, many political events. It's not enough to just be a news reporter. You have to understand politics. You need to have a highly developed bullshit radar and a natural capacity for joining the dots. And that is a special skill.
She has a point. A fearful number of press releases come into our inbox when we have a sitting Parliament, with parties pushing stories that flatter them, or if they're in Opposition, accusing the Government of all sorts of malfeasance. A lot of these stories do need to have context around them. If a party's claiming credit for a successful policy outcome, it gives context if you're able to point out the policy was actually introduced under a previous government, for example. It's a tough job. A bit like the job of the MPs that they're reporting on, it's one that's reasonably well paid, but the hours are dreadful and unorthodox. You have to live in Wellington. You have to be prepared for the vitriol, and kind of embedded, you all become, you all become one and the same.
I suppose it's a bit like being a sports reporter and travelling with the All Blacks. You become part of it, you know things that you won't report on because they're personal stuff, but you know them. It's a really close and intimate relationship. But one where you have to be able to make the hard call to report a story where perhaps you might quite like the individual as a human, but they have failed in their job. And you have to report it and you have to live with it. You have to be prepared for vitriol from those you're reporting on and those you're reporting to, to the reporters who think that you're biased or unfair or stupid or fat or ugly if you're a woman. All of that. You have to be prepared to put your head above the parapets.
Linda puts it really well when she says, when she says in the Spinoff article, you have to read a lot to write a little. To know enough, I mean it's very easy just to report the bureaucratic speak and political speak, but to make it understandable and to be able to put it into words we can all understand, you have to know so much more to be able to write a little. But a political editor's going the way of the beta tapes they used to record their interviews on. I hope not. Personally, I need people with experience and expertise in their craft to help explain what is sometimes a real head scratcher. Like why are they doing this? What on earth's going on? How can this possibly be seen to be a good idea?
Tell me Audrey Young in the Herald is not worth every cent she's paid. Yeah, we are not disestablishing the role at ZB, we're just trying to find the right person for the role and the one who wants to move to Wellington, wants to manage a team of young reporters. You have to have been there, you can't just parachute somebody in. You have to know what you're talking about and you have to know the people you're talking about. But to come back to the salient point I suppose, Linda says consumers of news want help to know what is important and what is worth their time. Political editors know the difference between BS and spin and real news. She says we need to have them in our media organisations. Do you agree?
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. - A group of 45 academics and constitutional experts has written an open letter calling for changes to the MMP electoral system to avoid undemocratic elections going into the future. The 11 seat overhang, which initial results are giving us before final votes are counted, is not what most voters of any side surely wants to see.
According to Andrew Geddis, the four seat overhang for Te Pāti Māori was the result of a deliberate campaign to expand its influence and try to engineer a left block win. National's seven seat overhang, he says, was more an organic result of the party continuing to do well in electorates while the party vote fell away. And we know where a significant number of former National voters went – they went to ACT, they went to New Zealand First, and a few went to The Opportunity Party.
The academics and the experts are coming at the overhang situation as being unfair. Andrew Geddis says the overhang could deliver a result where you have three parties that have a majority of seats in the house but have received fewer votes across the country than the other four. And he says one of the reasons people were keen on shifting to MMP was that in the past, First Past the Post delivered a government that had less votes than Labour. Labour might have earned more votes across the country, National had more seats, therefore they were the Government. But that's not the case here. Preliminary results show the country gave 50.36% of the vote to the parties of the Government —National, ACT, and New Zealand First— versus 43.63% of the vote to the Opposition —Labour, Greens, and Te Pāti Māori— and 6.0% to The Opportunity Party.
At the moment, you could argue that it is fair. There are more voters, by a small margin, who want to see the Government return than want to see the parties of the left take the government seats. The academics point out it was a 6% drop for the right from 2023 when they won 56% of the vote. So it was a drop. There was dissatisfaction. Opportunity came along bright and shiny and new and new ideas and people thought, "Yes please, give me some of that," and voters went away from the two main parties, not just National, but Labour. The balance could change once the special votes are counted and the finals will be tallied in a few weeks.
Even with TOP taken into account though, even if you put TOP in there, it's still a narrow win to National. So why is there grizzling from the academics? If they were concerned about the overhang situation full stop, I'd be more inclined to listen to them. I don't want to pay for 11 extra MPs with all their accommodation allowances and their flights up and down the country and their wages and their extra super that we top up. I'm really not of a mind to do that because I don't think we are being served well by a number of our politicians. There are some there who work like Trojans, who do an amazing job on behalf of the country, but there are some there who would not know their arse from their elbow. And with 11 more, you can bet your bottom dollar that while we might get some hard workers, we'll also get people who have no idea what they're doing.
As it stands, it's a narrow win to the right block parties, even with TOP taken into account. It's going to take quite a bit from the specials, which traditionally go left. Even then, it's not an egregious example of disproportionality. It's not like you've got 60% of the vote going to Labour and yet they still cannot form a government, or 60% go to the left block and they still can't form a government because of the electorate seats.
I'd be more inclined to think that this kind of open letter is not going to restore confidence in the electoral system, but it's going to detract from confidence in academics and experts who look like they're just being poor sports. I don't really understand why they are so concerned about unfairness, disproportionality, when at the moment it's nothing like '78 or '81. But there have been times, in this case there were votes for other parties that were simply discarded. Other minor parties back before we had MMP might have got 6%, 5%, 8% of the vote and they were completely and utterly disregarded. We're fairer now than we were under First Past the Post in terms of representation. And if the Government does get back in, they will have 1% more of the votes along with more electorate seats.
Why now? Why send the letter out now? It seems very odd. I don't want to see more MPs in Parliament, that's why I'd like the overhang got rid of. They're saying it's because MMP's not working the way it was supposed to. Well, yeah. If you can play the system the way Te Pāti Māori did, the way some former National supporters wanted you to do, like Harry Mowbray, that's the way it works. If you vote for a right block party like ACT because you don't think National's going hard enough, that's the way MMP works. So what, they want to do away with the entire system or just tweak it so that Labour wins next time round? Because that's what it's looking like.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. Sir Lockwood Smith: Former Speaker of the House on MMP and the impact it's had on NZ
18/11/2026 | 4 mins.A former Speaker of the House believes there needs to be a serious review of MMP.
The most recent election has resulted in, on preliminary results, both National and Te Pāti Māori having at least five more seats than their party vote entitles them to through an overhang.
This has sparked conversations around whether MMP is broken and calls for the overhang to be fixed.
Sir Lockwood Smith told Kerre Woodham this will be the fourth election now where the people vote, but at the end of the day, half a dozen people chose the government.
He says no system is perfect, but that's about as flawed as it's possible to be.
Smith says MMP has turned Parliament from the Citizens' Council to a place of political parties —of which very few New Zealanders are a part of— and so political activists are dominating what was meant to be a place of the people's representatives.
LISTEN ABOVE
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.Andrew Geddis: Otago University Law Professor on MMP, the open letter warning about the risks of the overhang
17/11/2026 | 10 mins.A call for our politicians to sit in a room together and try to find solutions to MMP, for themselves.
On preliminary results, both Te Pāti Māori and National have at least five more seats than their party vote entitles them to through the overhang.
An open letter from 46 experts, including former Prime Minister Geoffrey Palmer, is calling on a cross-party group to fix the problem now before trust in the system erodes.
Otago University Law Professor Andrew Geddis told Kerre Woodham the problem with the overhang is it risks delivering a government to parties that receive fewer votes than those in opposition.
He says that sort of risk undermines the purpose of elections, which is to find out what the majority wants and deliver government to that majority.
LISTEN ABOVE
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
More News podcasts
Trending News podcasts
About Kerre Woodham Mornings Podcast
Join Kerre Woodham one of New Zealand’s best loved personalities as she dishes up a bold, sharp and energetic show Monday to Friday 9am-12md on Newstalk ZB. News, opinion, analysis, lifestyle and entertainment – we’ve got your morning listening covered.
Podcast websiteListen to Kerre Woodham Mornings Podcast, Pod Save America and many other podcasts from around the world with the radio.net app

Get the free radio.net app
- Stations and podcasts to bookmark
- Stream via Wi-Fi or Bluetooth
- Supports Carplay & Android Auto
- Many other app features
Kerre Woodham Mornings Podcast: Podcasts in Family





































