In this episode, Clayton and Sam discuss the current landscape of the pet industry, highlighting the winners and losers, including veterinary practices, direct-to-consumer companies, and the rise of gently cooked pet foods. They explore the dynamics of veterinary diets, the influence of big box retailers, and the growing trust in creators over traditional companies. The conversation delves into the complexities of consumer trust, the need for a balanced ecosystem in pet retail, and the evolving preferences of pet owners.takeawaysVeterinary practices are oligopolistic and have raised prices without affecting margins.Direct-to-consumer companies are disrupting traditional pet food markets.Gently cooked foods are gaining popularity due to their convenience and appeal.Veterinary diets remain a trusted source for pet nutrition despite criticism.Big box retailers are expanding their pet product offerings significantly.Creators are becoming trusted sources of information for pet health and nutrition.Consumer trust in veterinarians is being challenged by online information.The pet food market is shifting towards more budget-friendly options.The ecosystem of pet retail needs to support both online and brick-and-mortar businesses.The influence of social media is reshaping consumer perceptions of pet food.Sound Bites"DTC companies are disrupting the market.""Creators are trusted more than companies.""People trust independence a lot more."
-------- Â
29:22
--------
29:22
D2C Market Spamming
n this conversation, Clayton Payne and Sam discuss the marketing strategies and business models of Butternut Box, a prominent player in the pet food industry. They analyze the effectiveness of its marketing, the implications of its business model, and the competitive landscape it faces. The discussion also touches on the future of pet food innovations and insights from the recent Pats trade show, emphasizing the importance of innovation in the pet industry.takeawaysThe customer acquisition cost must be lower than customer value.Spamming the market is not effective marketing.Butternut Box's business model relies heavily on investor funding.Market penetration is crucial for brand visibility.Competition in the pet food industry is fierce and evolving.Retail strategies are essential for long-term success.Innovation is key to standing out in trade shows.The pet food market is influenced by consumer convenience.Investors are looking for significant returns on their investments.The future of pet food may shift towards more convenient options.titlesDisrupting the Pet Food MarketThe Marketing Dilemma of Butternut BoxSound Bites"It's impossible to compete against them.""They want an exit.""Has this ever been done before?"Chapters00:00The Marketing Landscape of Pet Food02:34Butternut Box: Market Penetration and Strategy05:05Profitability and Business Models in Pet Food07:36Competition and Market Dynamics10:35Future of Pet Food: Trends and Innovations13:01Insights from the Pats Trade Show
-------- Â
28:19
--------
28:19
The Dumbest Marketing
In this episode, Clayton and Sam discuss the shortcomings of marketing strategies in the pet food industry, particularly focusing on a recent ad campaign by Pure Pet Food that they find tone-deaf. They explore the importance of understanding consumer needs and the viability of new products, such as freeze-dried dog food and postbiotics. The conversation also highlights the challenges of educating consumers about new dietary options for pets and the necessity for targeted marketing strategies that resonate with specific consumer problems.takeawaysThe marketing in the pet food industry often misses the mark by focusing on the company's achievements rather than customer needs.Investors should be wary of companies that prioritize ego over product quality.Consumer education is crucial for new products like postbiotics and insect-based diets.The pet food industry sometimes advances innovations that do not resonate with consumers.Targeted marketing is essential; generic approaches waste advertising budgets.Understanding the differences between prebiotics, probiotics, and postbiotics is important for pet health.The viability of new pet food products depends on consumer acceptance and understanding.Companies need to drill down on their unique selling propositions to stand out.The pet food market is competitive, and companies must focus on specific consumer needs.Marketing strategies should prioritize consumer problems over company growth narratives.titlesThe Flaws in Pet Food MarketingConsumer Insights in the Pet IndustrySound Bites"The customer doesn't want insects.""Most dogs don't need probiotics.""They're talking about themselves, Clayton."
-------- Â
20:24
--------
20:24
Navigating Competition in the Pet Food Market
summaryIn this conversation, Clayton Payne and Sam discuss the evolving landscape of the pet food industry, focusing on the impact of regenerative farming practices, the scale of major companies, and the challenges faced by challenger brands. They explore the importance of branding and marketing strategies, the role of China in manufacturing, and the cultural differences in pet care that influence innovation in the industry.takeawaysRegenerative farming practices are being adopted in the pet food supply chain.The scale of major pet food companies is often underestimated.Challenger brands must find their niche to compete effectively.Branding and marketing are crucial for success in the pet food market.The veterinary prescription diet model is difficult to penetrate for new brands.China plays a significant role in pet product manufacturing but lacks innovation.Innovation in the pet industry often comes from Western markets.Cultural differences affect how pets are treated and marketed in different regions.Challenger brands should focus on a narrow offering before expanding.The average consumer's lack of education impacts their purchasing decisions.Sound Bites"Branding is very, very important.""The average consumer isn't educated.""The West is the best."Chapters00:00The Scale of Pet Food Industry Partnerships03:34Navigating Competition in the Pet Food Market08:21Branding and Marketing in Pet Food13:31The Role of China in Pet Industry Innovation
-------- Â
27:58
--------
27:58
The Premiumisation of Cat
summaryIn this conversation, Clayton Payne and Sam discuss the evolving landscape of the pet industry, focusing on profitability, innovation in cat products, the challenges of raw feeding, consumer behavior in pet nutrition, and the importance of breed-specific nutrition. They also explore market gaps in pet food and supplements, innovative approaches to pet food, and the misuse of LinkedIn for product sales.takeawaysThere are many niches to explore in the pet industry.Premiumization of cat products is a significant growth area.Most new cat products will fail due to lack of innovation.Cats are sensitive to food temperature, affecting raw feeding.Consumer behavior towards cats differs from dogs, impacting nutrition choices.Breed-specific nutrition can address common health issues in pets.Market gaps exist for innovative pet food and supplements.Convenience and quality are key in pet food innovations.LinkedIn is not an effective platform for B2C product sales.Personal branding on LinkedIn should focus on industry-related content.titlesUnlocking Profitability in the Pet IndustryInnovating Cat Products for Modern ConsumersSound Bites"75% of new cat products will fail.""Your customers are not on LinkedIn.""It's not Facebook or Instagram."Chapters00:00Exploring Profitability in the Pet Industry02:26Innovations in Cat Products05:20The Shift Towards Cooked and Raw Pet Foods07:47Understanding Consumer Behavior in Pet Nutrition10:10The Potential of Breed-Specific Supplements12:45Identifying Gaps in the Pet Food Market15:16The Role of Convenience in Pet Food Innovations17:40Critique of LinkedIn as a Sales Platform for Pet Products
Real Pet Industry News brings you raw, unfiltered commentary on the latest trends, controversies, and innovations shaping the pet industry. Hosted by Clayton Payne (Pet Business Disruptors) and Sam Muelas (Dog and Cat Nutrition on YouTube), this podcast cuts through the noise to deliver real talk on everything from pet food scandals to game-changing business moves. Whether you're a pet industry pro, entrepreneur, or just a passionate pet owner, Clayton and Sam break it all down with expert insight, sharp opinions, and no-nonsense discussions.
New Zealand