517 | Debunking the Claims of a Seventh Century Mohammad , Ep5
In this episode Al Fadi and Dr Jay recap the first eleven claims; in conclusion : every reference to Mohammad in these claims place him in the wrong place and probably refer to other Muhammads = " the praised ones ". Then they discuss claim #12 The Ashtiname Letter, which was supposed to be written by Mohammad or Ali to the monks of St Catherine's Monastery, promising protection and other privileges. This turned out to be a fraud written by the monks of the monastery to protect themselves from the Marauding Muslims all around them.See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
--------
26:27
516 | Debunking the Claims of a Seventh Century Mohammad - Ep4
Al Fadi and Dr Jay discuss two more claims; Claim # 10 is John Nikiou, An Egyptian Coptic Bishop, who mentions Muhammad and Islam. The problem of this claim is that the earliest manuscript of this quote is from the 1700 AD and not the 7th century. Claim #11 John of Damascus, 730 AD, He mentions Muhammad as a false prophet, who taught the heresy of the Ishmaelites, who had four revelation three of them are called Suras in today's Quran. This is hardly a compliment to Islam or Muhammad.See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
--------
28:40
515 | Debunking the Claims of a Seventh Century Mohammad - Ep3
In this episode Al Fadi and Dr jay debunk five more claims: #5 John of Antioch in 639 AD, # 6 Ishoyahb III in 647 AD , # 7 The Armenian Bishop Sebeos in 660 -670 AD, # 8 Monothelite Christian in 662 AD, #9 John Bar Penkaye, a Nestorian Christian in 690 Ad. in some of these claims it is only an argument between a trinitarian and anti trinitarian and in others there is no mention of the Quran, Muslim or Islam.See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
--------
25:50
514 | Debunking the Claims of a Seventh Century Mohammad. Ep2
Al Fadi and Dr Jay refute the first four claims : 1. Thomas the Presbyter (634AD), who refers to a battle between the Romans and a "Tayaye d-Mhmt" which happened east of Gaza in 634 AD. 2. A flyleaf (634 AD), this refers to a battle of Yarmuk between the Syrians and the Arab of Mhmud. 3. The Sophronius and Jerusalem (637 AD). A Christian account of the conquest of Jerusalem in 637 AD by the Caliph Umar. 4. The Pact of Umar(637 AD). See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
--------
25:00
513 | Debunking the Claims of a Seventh Century Mohammad. Ep 1
In the Standard Islamic Narrative, Muslims claim that Muhammad lived in the seventh century in western Arabia (Mecca, Medina ) between 570-632 AD. In this new series Al Fadi and Dr Jay are going to use outside sources, none Islamic, to debunk any external evidence that is used to claim that the Mohammad of Islam did exist in the seventh century. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Listen to New Podcast Let Us Reason - A Christian/Muslim Dialogue, The BEMA Podcast and many other podcasts from around the world with the radio.net app
New Zealand